Bringing Up Bébé: A Modern Mom’s Reflection on French Parenting Wisdom
“There is no such thing as perfect parenting, only different styles shaped by culture.”
When I first heard about Bringing Up Bébé, I was navigating my own chaotic toddler days as a new mom in India. Between sleepless nights, food rejections, and a never-ending chorus of “why,” I stumbled upon this book that promised a calmer, more balanced approach to parenting.
Pamela Druckerman, a former Wall Street Journal reporter, writes about her experience raising her children in Paris. Through the eyes of an American mom surrounded by French parents, she uncovers what makes French kids seem more well-behaved, independent, and less fussy.
And let me say this: whether you’re skeptical or curious, Bringing Up Bébé will definitely make you reflect on your own parenting philosophy.
What Is Bringing Up Bébé About?
At its core, Bringing Up Bébé is about the cultural contrast between American (or even Indian) parenting styles and French parenting methods. Druckerman introduces us to:
- The concept of “cadre” – a firm framework with freedom within.
- French kids who sleep through the night by 2-3 months.
- Children who say please, wait patiently, and eat vegetables without negotiations.
- Mothers who aren’t martyrs to their parenting duties but still prioritize self-care.
She explores how French society supports parents through state-sponsored daycare (crèches), long maternity leaves, and a social belief in early autonomy.
Key Takeaways from Bringing Up Bébé
1. The Pause
French parents don’t rush to pick up their crying babies. They wait a few seconds to observe. This “pause” helps babies learn to self-soothe.
“French parents believe even a newborn can start to develop patience.”
When I tried this with my daughter, it worked. Within days, her frequent midnight cries reduced. Sleep training became less traumatic. Science backs this up too: according to a 2011 Pediatrics journal study, infants who learn to self-soothe have better sleep outcomes long-term.
2. Say No with Authority, Not Anger
French kids are not little tyrants. Saying “no” is part of their upbringing, but it’s delivered with calm firmness.
“C’est moi qui décide.” (I decide.)
I often say this now (in English!) when my son insists on chocolate before lunch. Consistency, I’ve learned, matters more than yelling.
3. Three Meals, One Snack
French children eat breakfast, lunch, gouter (around 4 p.m.), and dinner. That’s it.
Compare that to the constant snacking we sometimes allow. Indian households (including mine) often have the kitchen open all day! After applying this principle, meal battles drastically reduced.
A 2023 study by the European Journal of Clinical Nutrition found that structured meals lower obesity risk in children by 22%.
4. Moms Matter Too
In France, being a mother doesn’t mean losing your identity. French moms go back to work, maintain social lives, and prioritize personal time.
This was a wake-up call for me. I realized I was burning out because I felt guilty doing anything for myself. Inspired by Druckerman, I started a weekly coffee date with friends, and my mental health improved noticeably.
5. Delayed Gratification Is Taught Early
French kids are taught to wait, whether it’s for food, toys, or answers. This promotes patience and emotional regulation.
Psychologist Walter Mischel’s famous “marshmallow experiment” shows that children who can delay gratification tend to be more successful later in life. This isn’t just a cultural quirk – it’s a skill.
Controversies: Is French Parenting Really That Perfect?
Let’s be real – no parenting style is flawless. Critics argue that Bringing Up Bébé overly romanticizes French methods. Some Reddit threads, especially on r/AttachmentParenting, point out that the book assumes a level of privilege many parents simply don’t have.
Common Criticisms:
- French daycare is heavily state-subsidized; not all countries offer this.
- Not all children will magically eat beets and blue cheese.
- Not all moms want to separate so early from their infants.
Still, many readers (myself included) feel there is wisdom in balance. As one Redditor puts it:
“I took what felt right and left the rest.”
Bringing Up Bébé vs. Bébé Day by Day
Pamela Druckerman also wrote a follow-up: Bébé Day by Day, a practical version with 100 key insights. Think of it as the CliffsNotes for busy parents.
While Bringing Up Bébé is reflective and anecdotal, Bébé Day by Day is action-oriented. Personally, I keep both – one on my nightstand and the other near the kitchen!
Parenting Style Comparison: France vs. India vs. USA
| Aspect | France | India | USA |
|---|---|---|---|
| Food Habits | Structured, less snacking | Home-cooked, often flexible | Mix of home-cooked & processed |
| Discipline Style | Calm but firm | Mixed (authoritarian or indulgent) | Gentle to permissive |
| Sleep Routines | Babies sleep through early | Co-sleeping common | Mix of crib & co-sleeping |
| Parental Identity | Mom as individual | Mom as caretaker | Balance varies by family |
| Social Support | State-supported childcare | Family-supported | Paid care or independent |
Where to Find Bringing Up Bébé ?
- Paperback: Available on Amazon India (INR 1,053) and Flipkart.
- Epub & Kindle: On Amazon Kindle Store
- PDF: Look for authorized excerpts on publisher sites only. Avoid pirated copies.
Goodreads & Amazon Reviews
- Goodreads: 4.0/5 (74,000+ ratings)
- Amazon: 4.6/5 (6,500+ reviews)
Common praise includes:
- “Changed how I view parenting.”
- “Funny, honest, and surprisingly practical.”
Critics say:
- “Not all advice is feasible outside France.”
- “Glosses over socio-economic factors.”
Frequent Doubts Parents Ask (and Honest Answers!)
1. Will “The Pause” make my child feel abandoned?
No. It’s about a few seconds, not neglect. Always trust your instinct, but try observing first before reacting.
2. Can Indian kids really eat like French children?
With exposure and patience, yes. Start small – add one new veggie weekly. Model the behavior you want to see.
3. Is French parenting too cold?
It’s not about being cold, it’s about encouraging independence. Emotional warmth and autonomy can coexist.
4. Does this work for working moms only?
Not at all. Stay-at-home moms can apply these principles too. It’s about mindset, not lifestyle.
Final Thoughts: My Take as a Mom
As a modern Indian mom juggling parenting, career-building, and blogging, Bringing Up Bébé didn’t give me a perfect formula – but it gave me perspective.
I now:
- Observe before reacting.
- Encourage my kids to wait (even if it’s tough).
- Eat as a family.
- Respect my own needs, not just theirs.
Parenting doesn’t have to be exhausting. French moms aren’t superheroes – they just trust their kids more and expect more from them.
So, if you’re a mom or dad overwhelmed by today’s intensive parenting culture, pick up Bringing Up Bébé. It won’t solve all your problems, but it might just transform the way you see them.
Quote to Remember:
“It’s not about doing more for your kids. It’s about doing less, so they learn to do more.”
Leave a Reply